In Memory of Echo, Wolf 914F

No charges were pressed against the Utah cougar hunter who killed Echo the wandering wolf a year ago today, December 28th, 2014… “I had a shot and took it.” “Echo” | YouTube

The wolf known as 914F and later dubbed “Echo” (named by a 10-year-old boy from Oregon) was shot and killed outside Beaver, Utah, by a hunter who “mistook” the collared female wolf for a coyote. USFWS Investigators concluded, at that time, that the hunter honestly “mistook” shooting the collared, 89 pound, 3 year old female wolf for a 20 to 50 pound coyote — coyotes are not only legal to hunt year-round in Utah, but are subject to a $50.00 bounty.

The wildlife managers’ decision not to prosecute simply reinforces a double standard when it comes to killing endangered wildlife: All hunters have to do is claim they thought they were aiming at something legal to kill.

The gray wolf remains a protected species under the U.S. Endangered Species Act outside of the three state Northern Rockies recovery zone of Idaho, Montana and Wyoming. Federal law provides criminal penalties for those who “knowingly” kill protected animals. But “unknowingly” is a completely different.

The so-called “McKittrick Policy” was enacted after a Montana man gunned down a wolf and later claimed he had thought he was firing on a dog. He was prosecuted, though the Department of Justice  later decided to accept his self-exoneration by claimed ignorance, and has clung to that policy of inaction for years. Sign a petition here, to direct the Department of Justice to revise its self-imposed restriction on prosecutions of those who kill an endangered species and later claim to have not intended to do so.


“The Federal Wildlife Services’ (FWS) recent decision not to imprison, fine, nor even revoke the hunting license of the cougar hunter who killed wolf 914f, aka Echo, is illustrative of the hold that evolution has on us when it comes to predators.

The decision also illustrates how our irrational behavioral biases permeate our institutions and often lead to poor policy decisions, e.g., the Division of Natural Resources’ Predator Control Program, which offers a $50 bounty for each dead coyote and, ultimately, serves as the context and justification for the destruction of wolf 914f.

However, the facts of 914f’s killing underscore the extent of the hunter’s folly and, indeed, the folly of the FWS, for whom a dead wolf, the rule of law and the designation of endangered species would appear to mean less than the hunters’ highly dubious explanation of what occurred”…

“Wolves, coyotes and humans are very different animals, but we are all predators. That our own behavior as such is viewed any differently is not the result of humanity’s inherent or God-given uniqueness or superiority, but of accident, whereby we, as the benefactors of conditions and natural forces we personally had nothing to do with creating, get to say and do anything that we want to our fellow creatures and to the environment, no matter how outrageous, irrational and destructive.”~ Maximilian Werner 


Copyright © 2015 [COPYRIGHT Intheshadowofthewolf, name and webpage]. All Rights Reserved.

No part of this publication may be reproduced or distributed in any form or by any means, or stored in a database or retrieval system, without the prior written permission of the publisher.

18 thoughts on “In Memory of Echo, Wolf 914F

  1. This is a heartbreaking story and something that should have had consequences. When are the hunters going to have to obey the law and be held accountable for their cruel behavior towards our beautiful wild animals?

  2. Your petition is so important, but unfortunately, being outside the US, I’m unable to sign. I hope you get many many signatures so these beautiful animals get better protection

  3. This is so sad. Please leave our wild life alone and let them live in peace and harmony. They aren’t trophies. This is so sad and heartbreaking. R.I.P ECHO

  4. This is heart breaking. I wonderful wolve just starting its life killed. It makes me sick. This person should be made to pay for killing this gorgeous animal.

  5. When are we going to have laws that actually protect wildlife instead of “sporting rules” that seem to trump the laws and allow (encourage) hunters to shoot b4 they really know what they are shooting at. No one should be able to shoot at something unless they know exactly what it is they are shooting at. Guns kill and people with guns that don’t know what they are doing kill tragically.

  6. I also dislike the fact that wolves who are tracked with collars have numbers assigned to them instead of names. To the average “joe” 914F sounds more like a “what” than a “who”. Tagged animals need to be given names so that people can identify them as a living soul and not as a thing. I’m renaming 914F (post humously ) as “Zeus”.

    1. Please, her name was Echo.
      Echo’s name was chosen by a 10-year-old boy from Oregon, after a contest sponsored by conservation groups drew more than 500 entries. He said he chose the name “because she came back to the Grand Canyon like an Echo does.”
      In his winning contest entry, Zachary said he cares about wolves because “they are a part of the food chain, and they are so beautiful and we need them. All of them. All of every creature. We need them. ”

Comments are closed.